Bank Valuation Lower Than the Purchase Price, or Factory Loan Rejected? What to Do in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam

Written by , PEA 1478 · Published · Buying a factory or industrial land

Short answer

A bank lends on the lower of the purchase price and its panel valuer's market value, which rests on registered sales of similar factories. If valued below your SPA price, check the comparables, ask for a review, try another bank, renegotiate or fund the gap. If the loan is rejected, ask why, check CCRIS and contact MyKNP.

An older single-storey detached factory with weathered metal cladding and a closed roller shutter, with a blank clipboard and a white hard hat on a loading bay ledge in front.
Illustrative image

Key Takeaways

  • The bank lends on the lower figure. Alliance Bank's business premises financing sheet applies its margin to the purchase price, its panel valuer's valuation or its own valuation, whichever is lower. A valuation below your SPA price becomes cash you have to find.
  • A bank valuation is an opinion built on registered sales. The Board of Valuers' standard on methods requires the valuer to list each comparable by lot or title number, date, price and land area, and to disclose any registered sale of the same property in the two years before the valuation.
  • Thin evidence widens the gap in these areas. In JPPH-registered data, Serendah recorded 8 detached factory sales in 24 months and Rawang and Kundang 6 warehouse sales, so a large unit there is valued on few close comparables.
  • A rejection has reasons you can ask for. Ask the bank first, pull the company's free CCRIS report from Bank Negara, then use MyKNP, the advisory channel BNM runs with CGC and AKPK for unsuccessful SME applicants.
  • Most fixes happen before the SPA: the CCC and approved plans in hand, the title and lease checked, accounts and guarantors lined up, and cash set aside for a shortfall.

What is the difference between a bank valuation and the market price?

People say "market price" for two different things: the asking price on a listing, and what similar factories actually sold for. A bank valuation is neither. It is a registered valuer's opinion of market value, which the Board of Valuers' standard on market value defines as the estimated amount for which a property should exchange on the date of valuation between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm's-length transaction after proper marketing, with both parties acting knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion.

The standard on valuations for financing adds that a valuation for a loan must be on that market value basis and in a full report, and that a forced sale value has little or no relevance unless the bank asks for one. So the bank is not asking what the factory would fetch in a hurry; it is asking what it should fetch in a normal sale.

The price in your SPA is one deal between two parties. The valuer may look at it, because the standard on methods lets the valuer consider sale and purchase agreements, offers and bids for the property. But the figure in the report has to stand on comparable evidence. For any property above RM200,000, the comparables relied on must be shown, each identified by lot or title number, transaction date, price, a short description and land area.

That is why the gap tends to open on the units buyers like most: a detached factory with a big yard, a warehouse with a high eave, a lot where the seller has priced in an extension. The valuer can only support what the registered evidence and the approved building support.

Why do valuations in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam fall short of the price?

Three local reasons come up when I set an asking price against registered deals.

Few comparables for large units. In JPPH-registered transactions for Rawang and Kundang, semi-detached factories are well covered: 129 deals in 24 months, median price RM4.3 million, typical range RM3.71 million to RM6.2 million, RM380 psf of land. Detached factories had 16 deals in the same period and warehouses 6. In Serendah, detached factories had 8 deals in 24 months with a typical range of RM5.89 million to RM17.75 million, while terrace factories had 256 and Bukit Beruntung was the most active park with 132 deals. A terrace unit in Bukit Beruntung has plenty of close evidence. A large detached factory in Serendah does not, so the valuer has to reach further in place and time and make bigger adjustments.

Recent registered deals below older ones. In Shah Alam, the like-for-like (same park, same type) semi-detached factory price change, last 12 months vs the 12 before, was -32% across 3 parks, and for terrace factories -11% across 5 parks. A seller who sets the price from the deals of two years ago can meet a valuer reading the latest ones.

Things in the price that are not in the property. Machinery, racking, an office fit-out or an add-on built without approval may sit inside the seller's price. The inspection standard only expects plant and machinery to be detailed where the valuation includes them, so ask the bank what the valuer was instructed to value. My guide on illegal factory extensions explains why floor area outside the approved plans causes trouble at loan stage.

Is a bank valuation accurate?

It is a professional opinion at a date, not a measurement, and two registered valuers can reach different figures for the same factory. The standards push it towards evidence. Under the inspection standard, the valuer must inspect inside and out, report the state of repair and any visible major defects, disclose any breach of statutory requirements the valuer is aware of, and explain any condition in the title that affects the value.

In practice, ask the bank for a copy of the report, or at least its list of comparables, and check four things: the same factory type, the same or a similar estate, similar land size and tenure, and deals that are recent. A leasehold semi-detached unit valued off freehold terrace sales, or off deals in another district, is worth raising with the banker. Registered sales are per square foot of land, so compare a semi-detached factory only with semi-detached factories.

The fee is part of your entry cost. RHB's property term loan sheet lists a valuation fee among the charges when you buy a completed property from a seller who is not a developer. Ask for the fee quote before the bank instructs the valuer.

The valuation came in below the SPA price: what can I do?

First work out the size of the problem. Suppose a semi-detached factory in Rawang is agreed at RM4.3 million, the registered median for that type, and the bank's valuer puts it at RM4.0 million. Using an 85% margin purely as an illustration (it is the margin in HSBC's business premises financing example), the loan is 85% of RM4.0 million, which is RM3.4 million, instead of 85% of RM4.3 million, which is RM3.655 million. The cash you need towards the price rises from RM645,000 to RM900,000, before stamp duty and legal fees.

Then go through the options in roughly this order:

  1. Read the comparables. If they are not like for like, raise it with the banker in writing and attach registered deals from the same estate.
  2. Ask for a review with new evidence. The methods standard lets the valuer consider sale agreements, offers and bids. For a tenanted factory the investment method values the rent, using rents of similar properties, and the valuer must say whether the rent is sustainable. A signed tenancy at a market rent helps; an inflated rent does not.
  3. Try a second bank. Each bank uses its own panel valuer, but the lower-of rule still caps the loan at the purchase price if the second figure comes in higher.
  4. Renegotiate. With the report's comparables in hand, a seller who wants a clean completion may accept a price nearer the valuation.
  5. Cover the gap. Pay it in cash, or offer extra security; HSBC's sheet notes the bank may ask for additional security anyway.
  6. Check the SPA early. Read the loan clause and the completion period with your lawyer as soon as the valuation arrives, not in the last week.

Does an old factory get a lower valuation?

Age itself is not the issue; what age does to the building, the paperwork and the lease is. Under the methods standard, a valuer using the cost method must state the depreciation or obsolescence deducted from the cost of the buildings, so worn cladding, a tired roof or an outdated layout shows up as a stated deduction. The inspection standard also asks the valuer to report the state of repair and visible major defects.

Older units also tend to raise three paperwork questions the valuer and the bank will see:

  • The CCC or CF. HSBC's business premises financing is for properties fully completed with a Certificate of Completion and Compliance. Have the CCC or CF and the approved building plans ready before the valuer visits. My guide on renting a factory without CCC or CF covers how to check with MPS, MPHS or MBSA.
  • Add-ons. Canopies, mezzanines and extra bays built after the CCC sit outside it.
  • Years left on the lease. The lease term is on the title, and the inspection standard requires the valuer to explain any title condition that affects the value. In Shah Alam's registered data there were 22 leasehold factory deals against 136 freehold, so leasehold evidence is thinner. My freehold and leasehold guide covers the remaining term, and where the title carries a restriction in interest, the bank's charge also needs state consent.

My factory loan was rejected: what should I do next?

  1. Ask the bank why, in writing. In 2013 the Association of Banks in Malaysia said participating banks would use a checklist showing where an SME application fell short, covering areas such as the business plan, collateral adequacy and credit history, and would try to meet the applicant or send a letter. BNM's MyKNP page also says to seek clarification from the bank first.
  2. Pull the company's CCRIS report. BNM's CCRIS FAQ says a person authorised by the company can collect it with a letter on company letterhead signed by the company secretary and at least two directors, plus certified copies of Form 9, Form 13 where it applies and Form 49. The report is free. It shows outstanding accounts and applications approved or pending in the last 12 months; rejected applications are not shown. Look for arrears and any account flagged for special attention, and check the directors' own reports too.
  3. Use MyKNP. It is a joint effort of BNM, CGC and AKPK giving advisory help to unsuccessful SME and home financing applicants: the reasons for the rejection, how to improve eligibility and other financing routes. For SME financing the contact BNM lists is CGC on 03-7880 0088 or imsme.com.my.
  4. Sort the reason into property or borrower. A property problem (no CCC, an unapproved extension, a title condition, a short lease) follows the factory to the next bank. A borrower problem (a short track record, losses, CCRIS arrears, a weak plan) follows the company to any factory.

Can a new or loss-making company get a factory loan?

It is harder, because the products are built around a track record. Alliance Bank's Business Premises Financing asks for a business established at least 3 years and lists a margin of up to 95% and tenure of up to 25 years; those are ceilings, not what every file gets. CIMB's SME Biz Property Financing, which covers industrial property and vacant land, asks a Sdn Bhd for its latest 3 years' audited accounts and management accounts and its latest 6 months' bank statements. Bank Muamalat's commercial property sheet says the bank may require a joint and several guarantee from the owner, a key director or a shareholder.

Routes worth discussing with the banker before you sign:

  • the directors' personal guarantee, backed by their own income and assets;
  • a larger down payment, so the bank lends less against the value;
  • buying in the name that has the track record (my guide on buying in a company or personal name sets out what changes);
  • explaining a loss year with the latest management accounts and what has changed since;
  • renting first, for example a factory for rent in Rawang, while the accounts build up.

Check the product's purpose too. HSBC's business premises financing is for properties at least 50% owner-occupied by the borrower or its group, so a company buying to let should ask for the bank's investment terms instead.

What documents do I need for a factory loan?

From the company, CIMB's list for a Sdn Bhd is a fair template: NRIC or passport copies, the latest 3 years' audited and management accounts, the latest 6 months' bank statements and the purchase documents (title copy, SPA or letter of offer). A sole proprietor or partnership gives its business registration, 3 years of management accounts, 6 months of statements and 3 years of income tax returns (Form B, P or PT).

From the property side, I ask the seller for these before the offer, so the buyer's bank and valuer have them on day one:

  • a title copy showing the tenure, the express condition and any restriction in interest;
  • the CCC or CF and the approved building plans;
  • the latest quit rent and assessment receipts;
  • the tenancy agreement, if the factory is let;
  • for a Bumi lot, the release or consent position.

How do I improve my chances before I sign?

  • Check the asking price against registered deals of the same type in the same estate before you make an offer.
  • Speak to the banker before the SPA with the title copy and the company accounts, and ask how the bank will assess a company of your age and size.
  • Match the product to the use: owner-occupied products such as HSBC's require at least 50% owner occupation.
  • Keep cash in reserve for a valuation shortfall, on top of stamp duty and legal fees.
  • Settle arrears showing in CCRIS before you apply, not after.
  • If the SPA timeline is tight, apply to more than one bank at the same time.
  • What is the interest rate for a factory loan? Rates for industrial property loans in Malaysia are near 4.50 percent, in line with how banks price factory and commercial property loans.
  • Can I use my existing factory as collateral to get a loan to buy a new factory? Yes. You can charge the factory you already own to a bank and use the financing it raises to buy another factory.
  • Can a factory be refinanced? Yes. A factory in Malaysia can be refinanced, and a cash-out refinance is possible within the bank's limits.
  • Can I buy a factory through Islamic Financing? Yes. Islamic financing is offered for factories in Malaysia alongside conventional loans, so you can buy through either route.

These questions are answered in full on FactoryHub.

If you are buying a factory in Rawang, Serendah or Shah Alam and want the price checked against registered deals before the bank's valuer sees it, WhatsApp Jason Low, Probationary Estate Agent PEA 1478 with CID Realtors, on +60 12-288 1834.

Questions people ask

01What is the difference between a bank valuation and the market price of a factory?+

The asking price is what the seller wants and the SPA price is what you agreed. The bank valuation is a registered valuer's opinion of market value: what the factory should sell for between a willing buyer and seller after proper marketing, supported by comparable registered sales. The bank lends on the lower of the price and the valuation.

02Is a bank valuation accurate?+

It is an opinion at a date, not a measurement, and two valuers can differ. The Board of Valuers' standards require the valuer to inspect the factory, list the comparables used and explain any title condition that affects the value. Ask the bank for the comparables and check they are the same type, estate, size and tenure.

03What happens if the bank valuation is lower than the SPA price?+

The margin is applied to the lower figure, so the loan shrinks and you pay the difference in cash. You can ask for a review with better comparables, try another bank's panel valuer, renegotiate the price or offer more security. Check the SPA's loan clause and completion period with your lawyer straight away.

04My factory loan was rejected. What should I do next?+

Ask the bank for the reasons in writing and pull the company's free CCRIS report from Bank Negara. Then contact MyKNP through CGC (03-7880 0088) for advice on the rejection and other financing routes. Decide whether the problem is the property or the borrower before you apply again.

05Can a new or loss-making company get a factory loan?+

It is harder because many products ask for a track record, for example 3 years in business at Alliance Bank or 3 years of audited accounts at CIMB. Banks may ask the directors or main shareholders to guarantee. A larger down payment, a guarantor with income, or renting first while the accounts build up are the usual routes to discuss.

06Does an old factory building lower the bank valuation?+

It can. Under the cost method the valuer must state the depreciation deducted for the buildings, and must report the state of repair and visible defects. Missing CCC or approved plans, add-ons outside the approved plans and a short remaining lease can also pull the value or the loan down.

07Can a foreign company apply for a factory loan for a factory in Rawang or Shah Alam?+

Yes, a foreign company can apply, but the bank assesses the local borrowing entity, its accounts and its guarantors, so confirm eligibility with the bank before you commit. CIMB's SME Biz Property Financing, for example, asks a Sdn Bhd for 3 years of audited accounts and 6 months of bank statements. On the property side, check the title and any restriction in interest at the land office, and ask MPS, MPHS or MBSA about the CCC and approved plans.

08Can foreign enterprises apply for factory loans in Malaysia, for example for a factory in Serendah or Shah Alam?+

Yes, but the bank looks at the Malaysian company that borrows, its accounts and its guarantors, so ask early how it treats a foreign shareholder. CIMB asks a Sdn Bhd for 3 years of audited accounts and 6 months of bank statements, and Bank Muamalat may ask an owner, key director or shareholder for a joint and several guarantee. Before you sign, check the title and any restriction in interest at the land office.

Sources

  1. FactoryHub: JPPH-registered industrial transactions, Rawang and Kundang
  2. FactoryHub: JPPH-registered industrial transactions, Serendah
  3. FactoryHub: JPPH-registered industrial transactions, Shah Alam
  4. Board of Valuers (LPPEH): Malaysian Valuation Standards, market value basis
  5. Board of Valuers (LPPEH): Malaysian Valuation Standards, valuations for financing purposes
  6. Board of Valuers (LPPEH): Malaysian Valuation Standards, inspection
  7. Board of Valuers (LPPEH): Malaysian Valuation Standards, methods of valuation
  8. Alliance Bank: Business Premises Financing product disclosure sheet
  9. Alliance Bank: Business Premises Financing
  10. HSBC Bank Malaysia: Business Premises Financing product disclosure sheet
  11. RHB: BizPower Property Term Loan product disclosure sheet
  12. Bank Muamalat: Commercial Property Financing-i product disclosure sheet
  13. CIMB: SME Biz Property Financing
  14. Bank Negara Malaysia: MyKNP
  15. Bank Negara Malaysia: CCRIS FAQ
  16. The Star: Reasons for rejected SME loans to be disclosed (2013)

Units on the market nearby

More on buying a factory or industrial land

All guides: Buying a factory or industrial land →

Probationary Estate Agent · PEA 1478 · CID Realtors Sdn Bhd E(1) 1855About Jason → · Contact →
Ask Jason about this