Who Pays for Repairs in a Rented Factory, Landlord or Tenant? Roof, Wiring, Drains and Outgoings in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam
The tenancy agreement decides, because no Malaysian statute splits repairs for a factory tenancy of three years or less. I ask that the landlord keeps the roof, structure, main switchboard and drains sound and pays quit rent, assessment and building insurance, while the tenant services its own wiring, air-conditioners and fittings and repairs damage it causes.
Key Takeaways
- The tenancy agreement decides. A factory tenancy of three years or less is exempt from registration, and disputes over it are settled under the Contracts Act 1950; no statute writes the repair split for you (PKNS paper on landlord and tenant law).
- Registered leases have a fallback. For a lease of more than three years, the National Land Code implies that the tenant pays most outgoings, though not quit rent, and keeps the property in repair, unless the lease says otherwise (National Land Code, sections 230 to 233).
- Quit rent and assessment are the owner's bills in law. If assessment falls into arrears, the council may seize movable property found on the factory, whoever owns it (Local Government Act 1976, sections 146 and 148), so a tenant should see the receipts.
- Electrical repairs need a competent person. Only a competent person may repair or service the installation, and a supply taken through switchgear of 100A or more needs at least one inspection visit a month (Electricity Regulations 1994, regulations 67, 110 and 111).
- Roof repair permits start with the owner. MPS asks for the owner's letter, the paid assessment bill and the CCC; MPHS lets a tenant apply with the tenancy agreement.
What does Malaysian law say when the tenancy agreement is silent?
Many factory tenancies are written for two or three years with an option to renew, which keeps each term within three years. Under section 223 of the National Land Code, a tenancy of three years or less is exempt from registration and can even be oral, and section 224 says an option to renew is ignored when the term is counted. A paper on landlord and tenant law published by PKNS sums up the result: Malaysia has no specific legislation governing tenancy agreements, the Contracts Act 1950 covers disputes over them, and a tenancy that is not registered or endorsed on the title is protected by contract law only. Who fixes the roof, the switchboard or the drains is therefore whatever the pages you sign say.
For a lease of more than three years, registered on the title, the Code fills the gaps. Unless the lease says otherwise:
- the tenant pays rates, taxes and other outgoings, but not the rent due to the State (quit rent), which stays with the landlord, nor any outgoing that a written law makes payable by the landlord alone (sections 230 and 231);
- the tenant keeps the property, including its boundary marks, in repair; where only part of a building is let, the landlord keeps the roof, main walls, main drains and common passages in repair (sections 231 and 232);
- "in repair" means the condition a prudent owner would keep the property in, and the tenant need not hand it back in better shape than at the start (sections 5 and 233);
- if the property becomes wholly or partly unfit for use through no fault of the tenant, the rent, or a fair share of it, stops until it is fixed, and if it is not fixed within six months the tenant may end the lease with one month's written notice (section 232).
For a whole detached or semi-detached factory on a long lease, that fallback puts almost every repair, roof included, on the tenant. On a short term that is a lot to accept, so I use these sections as a list of questions the agreement must answer either way. My guide on how long a factory lease should run covers the three-year registration point.
Who fixes a leaking roof in a Rawang, Serendah or Shah Alam factory?
The split I ask for is simple. The landlord repairs the roof sheets, skylights, flashing, gutters, downpipes and the steel structure. The tenant pays for damage it causes, for example brackets, pipes or panels fixed through the roof without consent, or gutters blocked by its own waste. A leak that reaches stock or machines is the tenant's insurance claim, because the owner's building policy covers the building, not the goods inside; FactoryHub's note on who insures what in a factory lease sets out the policies.
Roof work also needs the council's permit, and the forms show who has to sign. Rawang and Kundang fall under Majlis Perbandaran Selayang (MPS), Serendah, Sungai Choh, Bukit Beruntung and Batang Kali under Majlis Perbandaran Hulu Selangor (MPHS), and Shah Alam under MBSA (Selangor State Assembly written answer 346, Appendix A).
- MPS. The minor works permit form JB-B08 covers roof repairs that do not change the original structure. The application letter comes from the owner, with the title or sale agreement, the latest paid assessment bill and the CCC, plus a RM100 processing fee and a RM5 sticker.
- MPHS. The minor works checklist for non-residential buildings covers changing a roof finish, for example asbestos to metal deck, in the existing colour and without changing the original structure. A tenant can apply, with the current tenancy agreement and the latest assessment bill. MPHS charges RM100 per work item, a RM100 building material permit fee, a RM20 sticker, a RM500 permit deposit and a RM500 RORO compliance charge, and warns that starting before approval can cost ten times the processing fee.
- MBSA. Its Building Department issues temporary permits on standard plans and acts against unauthorised construction; ask it which permit your roof work needs before a contractor starts.
A new, partly new or raised roof is treated as erecting a building under section 70(16) of the Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974 and needs plan approval, so re-roofing is the landlord's project. In the agreement I ask for written notice of a leak, a response time both sides agree, the tenant's right to make an urgent temporary repair and recover the cost, and a rent reduction for any area that cannot be used.
Who looks after the switchboard, wiring and the monthly electrical inspection?
Electrical maintenance carries more rules than any other item. The Electricity Regulations 1994 say:
- the installation must be kept in good working order, and that duty lies with the owner, management, licensee or occupier, as the case may be (regulation 110(1) and (2)); the law leaves the choice between landlord and tenant to you;
- no one except a competent person, or someone working under one's control, may repair, replace, service or clean installation equipment (regulation 111);
- a low voltage installation receiving electricity through switchgear rated at 100A or more needs at least one inspection visit a month by an Electrical Services Engineer, Competent Electrical Engineer or Electrical Supervisor; above 600V and up to 11,000V it is two visits a month (regulation 67);
- a non-domestic installation must be checked and tested at least once every five years, and protective relays and devices every two years (regulation 110(3) and (4)).
The split I propose: the landlord hands over the main switchboard and incoming cables in working order, with the latest test report, and replaces main switchgear that fails from age. The tenant appoints and pays the competent person during its occupation, maintains the sub-boards and machine wiring it installs, and gets written consent before touching the main board. If the factory needs more power than it has, read my guide on sizing kVA and a TNB upgrade before you agree the rent.
Is a broken air-conditioner, blocked drain or cracked floor the tenant's problem?
These are where arguments about fair wear and tear start, so the handover record matters as much as the clause.
- Air-conditioners. The tenant services the units it uses; the landlord replaces units it supplied that fail from age. MPHS lists replacing an air-conditioning, sanitary or internal piping system, or the electrical wiring, as permit items on the same checklist, so a full replacement is a permitted job, not a service visit.
- Drains. Surface and storm water drains under the council's control are the council's to maintain (section 53, Act 133), but the council can serve a notice on the owner to repair or clean the drains on the premises (section 52(3)). I ask that the tenant keeps compound drains, sumps and grease traps clear day to day and the landlord repairs broken drains and covers.
- Floor. Cracks from settlement or a failed slab are the landlord's; damage from overloading, forklifts or machine bases is the tenant's. My guide on factory floor loading shows what to check before heavy machines go in.
- Toilets and fittings. Day-to-day repairs to taps, cisterns and lights sit with the tenant; worn-out pipes inside the walls with the landlord.
Quit rent, cukai pintu, insurance and the management fee: whose bill is it?
- Quit rent. It falls due in full on 1 January and is in arrears from 1 June (National Land Code, section 94). If it stays unpaid, the land administrator serves a notice of demand in Form 6A and can declare the land forfeit (sections 97 and 100). A tenant whose tenancy is endorsed on the title may pay the sum demanded and deduct it from rent (section 98). My quit rent guide has the Selangor rates.
- Assessment (cukai pintu). Rates are paid by the owner (Local Government Act 1976, section 146). For arrears, the council may seize movable property, to whomsoever belonging, found on the holding (section 148), which is why I ask the landlord to show the paid bill every half year. A tenant who pays the owner's rate may deduct it from the rent whatever the agreement says (section 155). The council rates are in my cukai pintu guide.
- Insurance. The owner insures the building; PIAM advises that the sum insured should reflect rebuilding cost, not market value. The tenant insures its stock, machinery, own fit-out and public liability.
- Management fee. It appears only where there is a strata scheme or a managed park. The KPKT Strata Management Handbook 2.0 lists paying the maintenance charge and the sinking fund as duties of the parcel owner and gives the roof as an example of common property. The maintenance charge pays for upkeep, cleaning, security and insurance premiums; the sinking fund pays for capital items such as repainting and replacing fittings. If a landlord passes the maintenance charge on, I ask that the sinking fund stays with the owner; my guide on negotiating factory rent covers the wording.
Which costs do factory tenants forget to budget for?
- The competent person. The monthly visits under regulation 67 and the five-yearly test, if the agreement puts them on you. Fees vary, so ask two or three registered electrical contractors for a quote before you sign.
- Fire protection. Servicing extinguishers, hose reels, alarms and sprinklers, and the yearly fire certificate where the premises are designated. Under section 33 of the Fire Services Act 1988 the owner commits the offence if no certificate is in force, so the lease should say who services and who pays; my guide to Bomba requirements for factories lists the systems.
- Permits. The MPHS fees and deposits above, or the RM100 and RM5 at MPS, for every repair that needs a permit.
- Outgoings passed through. Assessment, quit rent or a maintenance charge added on top of a net rent. Compare like with like against registered rents on FactoryHub's industrial transactions page.
- Reinstatement. Removing your partitions, mezzanine and wiring at the end; see my guide on reinstatement works.
- The deposit. The PKNS paper cites BBMB Kewangan Berhad v Kueh Teck Swee [2001] 2 AMR 1401: a landlord can use the deposit for repairs only where the agreement allows it.
How should the repair schedule in the tenancy agreement be written?
I ask for a one-page schedule attached to the agreement, item by item:
| Item | Landlord | Tenant |
|---|---|---|
| Roof sheets, gutters, steel structure | Repairs and replaces | Damage it causes; keeps gutters clear of its waste |
| Main switchboard, incoming cables | Working order at handover; replaces failed main switchgear | No changes without written consent |
| Sub-boards, machine wiring | Only what the landlord supplied | Maintains through a competent person |
| Competent person visits and tests | As agreed in writing | As agreed in writing |
| Air-conditioners | Replaces its own units that fail from age | Regular servicing |
| Compound drains and sumps | Structural repairs and covers | Keeps them clear |
| Floor slab | Settlement and structural cracks | Overloading and impact damage |
| Fire protection systems | Delivers them in working order | Servicing during the term, unless agreed otherwise |
| Quit rent, assessment | Pays and shows receipts | Only if agreed |
| Building insurance | Insures at rebuilding cost | Insures contents and liability |
| Maintenance charge, sinking fund | Sinking fund | Maintenance charge only if agreed |
Around the schedule go the clauses that make it work: a dated schedule of condition with photos at handover; written notice and agreed response times; the tenant's right to make urgent repairs and set off the cost; a rent reduction while part of the factory cannot be used; who signs the council permit forms (MPS needs the owner's letter); and what the deposit may be used for. If the factory sits in a managed park, my guide to managed parks versus older estates covers management fees and sinking funds.
What do I check on a site visit before a client signs?
When a client shortlists a factory for rent in Rawang, Serendah or Shah Alam, I walk the building with the schedule in hand:
- The underside of the roof and the skylights, ideally after rain, and stains on the office ceiling boards.
- Gutters, downpipes and where the water goes.
- The main switch rating, the competent person's logbook and the last test report.
- The age of each air-conditioner and who owns it.
- Compound drains, sumps and covers.
- Cracks in the floor slab and around machine bases.
- Service tags on the fire equipment, and the latest fire certificate if there is one.
- The latest assessment and quit rent receipts, and the management statement if the factory sits in a strata or managed park.
Each gap goes into the schedule as an owner's repair with a completion date, before the booking deposit is paid. For the building itself, my guide to inspecting a used factory covers roof leaks, rust, asbestos and wiring.
If you want the repair and outgoings split of a factory checked before you sign, WhatsApp Jason Low, Probationary Estate Agent PEA 1478 with CID Realtors Sdn Bhd, on +60 12-288 1834.
Questions people ask
01Is the landlord or the tenant responsible for a factory roof leak?+
It depends on the tenancy agreement, because no Malaysian statute splits repairs for a factory tenancy of three years or less. The split I ask for puts the roof sheets, gutters, downpipes and steel structure on the landlord and any damage from the tenant's own works on the tenant. Also write down how fast the landlord must respond and whether rent is reduced for an area that cannot be used.
02Who repairs the electrical system in a rented factory?+
The Electricity Regulations 1994 put the duty to maintain an installation on the owner, management, licensee or occupier, so the agreement has to choose. Only a competent person may repair or service the equipment, and a supply through switchgear of 100A or more needs a monthly inspection visit. I usually ask the landlord to hand over the main switchboard in working order and the tenant to pay the competent person and maintain its own sub-boards.
03Who pays the management fee for a rented factory?+
In a strata scheme the parcel owner is liable for the maintenance charge and the sinking fund, according to KPKT's Strata Management Handbook. A tenant pays only if the tenancy agreement says so. If the charge is passed on, keep the sinking fund with the owner and ask to see the latest statement before you sign.
04What hidden costs does a factory tenant pay besides rent?+
Common ones are the monthly competent person visits and electrical tests, fire system servicing, council permit fees for repairs, and assessment, quit rent or a maintenance charge added to a net rent. Reinstatement at the end of the tenancy and insurance for your own stock and machines also fall on you. Ask for each one to be named in the agreement.
05Can the landlord use my deposit to pay for repairs?+
Only if the tenancy agreement allows it. A PKNS paper on landlord and tenant law cites BBMB Kewangan Berhad v Kueh Teck Swee [2001] 2 AMR 1401, where the court held that the landlord's right to keep the deposit depended on the express terms. List what the deposit may cover and attach a dated photo record of the condition at handover.
06Do I still pay full rent if part of the factory cannot be used after a leak?+
For a registered lease of more than three years, the National Land Code stops the rent, or a fair share of it, while the property is unfit for use through no fault of the tenant, unless the lease says otherwise. For a shorter tenancy only the agreement can give you that right. Ask for a rent reduction clause tied to written notice of the defect.
Sources
- National Land Code (Act 828): sections 5, 94, 97, 98, 100, 223, 224 and 230 to 233 (FAOLEX copy of the official revised text)
- PKNS e-Perundangan: Landlord vs Tenant, rights and liabilities (Messrs Sidek Teoh Wong & Dennis), no specific tenancy legislation, deposit case law
- Local Government Act 1976 (Act 171): annual value, sections 146, 148 and 155 (DBKL copy)
- Suruhanjaya Tenaga: Electricity Regulations 1994, regulations 67, 110 and 111
- Laws of Malaysia: Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974 (Act 133), sections 52, 53 and 70(16) (AGC reprint)
- Majlis Perbandaran Selayang: Borang JB-B08, permit kerja-kerja kecil (bukan strata)
- Majlis Perbandaran Hulu Selangor: senarai semak permit kerja kecil bangunan selain kediaman
- Majlis Bandaraya Shah Alam: Jabatan Bangunan, functions and customer charter
- Dewan Negeri Selangor: written answer 346, Appendix A, industrial areas by local authority
- KPKT: Handbook Pengurusan Strata 2.0, maintenance charge, sinking fund and common property
- Laws of Malaysia: Fire Services Act 1988 (Act 341), section 33 (AGC reprint)
- PIAM: Understanding property insurance in Malaysia, sum insured at rebuilding cost
- FactoryHub: industrial transactions (JPPH-registered sales and tenancies)
Units on the market nearby
Semi-D Factory for Rent in Saujana Teknologi Rawang, Rawang, 6,525 sq ft
RM 10,500/month
Semi-Detached Factory for Sale or Rent in Saujana Rawang, Rawang, 8,000 sq ft
RM 4,000,000 · RM 15,000/month
Detached Factory for Rent in Batu 17 Rawang, 9,000 sq ft
RM 21,000/month
More on renting a factory or warehouse
- What to Check Before Renting a Factory in Rawang: Approvals, Power, Licences and Rent
- Rent or Buy a Factory in Malaysia? Rent vs Loan Instalment, Cash Tied Up, Tax and the Break-Even Point in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam
- Can You Terminate a Factory Tenancy Agreement Early in Rawang, Serendah or Shah Alam? Compensation, Break Clauses, a Replacement Tenant and Your Deposit
- SST on Factory Rental in Rawang, Serendah and Shah Alam: Who Pays the 6%, Which Tenants Are Exempt and What the Invoice Must Show